Search This Blog

Sunday, September 2, 2007

Words to live by

My Father

“The image of my father floats like a spectre before me as I try to form my thoughts about manhood. I see him as he is now – a shell of a man, lost in private memories, spending his days idly flicking a television from channel to channel in hopes of finding something to occupy his time. I see him as he is, but I remember him as he was….”

My Father

“With each passing day I realize more how much he lives within me, and how great a shadow he casts over my life. It is the same for all men. None of us can escape this shadow of the father, even if that shadow fills us with fear, even if it has no name or face. To be worthy of that man, to prove something to that man, to exocise the memory of that man from every corner of our life – however it affects us, the shadow of that man cannot be denied.”

My Father

“To become a father is to understand that power of that shadow from the other side. You realize that the touches you make upon your son will shape him, for better or worse, for his entire life.”


Being a Man and Male

… Being a man is something different. It is taking these male traits and forming them into a life that meets the demands of the world around you while serving the needs of others. It is action in service of a dream…

Being a Man and Male

“You were born into a different world that will present you with different gifts and challenges. A new vision of manhood will be called for that does not tie so closely into the more aggressive and competitive residues of our male character. You will need to search out new ways of expressing strength, showing mastery, and exhibiting courage – ways that do not depend upon confronting the world before you as an adversary.”

Being a Man and Male

“… when maleness operates untempered with moral value, it visits damage upon the earth.”

Being a Man and Male

“Being male is not enough; being a man is a right to be earned and an honor to be cherished.”


Being a Man and Male

“… the formation of your manhood must be a conscious act governed by the highest vision of the man you want to be.”

Being a Man and Male

“Most of all, do not fall prey to the false belief that mastery and domination are synonymous with manliness.”

Being a Man and Male

“Measure your greatness by the length of your reach, but also by the gentleness of your touch.”

Strength

“For ages we have lived with this biological imperative by which manhood has been defined as strength to master others, strength to master our emotions, strength to master the world around us.”

“The world doesn’t need this version of strength anymore. We are not locked in some physics of survival where we must turn force against counterforce in an elemental battle to see who will prevail. We need greatness of spirit more than we need greatness of physical strength.”

Strength

“But there is much more to strength than overcoming fear.”

“Martin Luther may have put it most succinctly when he stood up for his vision of God. ‘Here I stand,’ he said, ‘I cannot do otherwise.’

Strength

“Try to find this strength in yourself. It lies far below anger and righteousness and any impulse toward physical domination. It lies in a place where your heart is at peace.”

Strength

“Remember the words of Tao te Ching. ‘The only true strength is a strength that people do not fear.’ Strength based in force is strength people fear. Strength based in love is a strength people crave.”

Work

“Your work makes you who you are, because it is where you put your time.”

“We are what we do, and the more we do it, the more we become it.”

Work

“So a true vocation calls to you to perform it and it allows your life to speak.”

Work

“But now amount of security is worth the suffering of a life lived chained to a routine that has killed all your dreams.”

Money

“Yet money is not of central importance. It has nothing whatsoever to do with the lasting values that make life worth living.”

Money

“Knowing how to be poor means developing an unerring instinct for the difference between what is essential and what is only desirable. It means knowing how to take control of your life – how to repair and maintain the things around you, how to purchase wisely and well, how not to purchase at all when you do not have the means to do so, how to take joy in the simple pleasures in life.”

money means the loss of who they are. If you learn to accept poverty when it comes, it will make you clearer and stronger and more self-reliant. It will make you more appreciative of the simple gifts of life and will keep this appreciation close to the center of your heart. But you must learn to live by its rules. You must learn to embrace the life of limitations that it forces upon you.”

Tragedy And Suffering

You must embrace them and realize that they too, are a gift of life because they take you out of yourself and, for a moment, make you one with all others who have known loss or pain or suffering. The great lesson of suffering comes from the fact that it is so much greater than the confines in which we live our daily lives.”

“When we finally reclaim ourselves, as we ultimately do, we are changed. We have been dropped into chaos and nothing is as it was.”

Tragedy And Suffering

“Those who insulate themselves from further pain miss a great opportunity. They miss the chance to use their pain to grow outside themselves and recognize something greater and shared in our human experience.”

“Whatever it is, it is your measure, and you need to look upon it as a gift to help you reclaim what is important in your life.”


Tragedy And Suffering

“The question you must ask yourself is not if you will heal, but how you will heal. Grief and pain have their own duration, but when they begin to pass, you must take care to guide the shape of the new being you are to become.”

Loneliness And Solitude

Time spent alone returns to you a hundredfold, because it is the proving ground of the spirit.”

“Most people fear being alone because they understand only loneliness. They feel that unless the world presents them with a mirror in the form of another person responding to them, they are close to annihilation.”

“Solitude is a place you reach, not a decision you make.”

Fatherhood

“ So move cautiously toward fatherhood. It is much easier to become a father than to be one. When you become a father your whole life suddenly becomes measured against your vision of what good fatherhood should be.”


Fatherhood

“So look upon fatherhood as a gift. It is one of life’s common miracles, available to everyone and given freely to us all. A child, whether healthy or ill, misshapen or beautiful, opens the world into a new sunlight. It is an experience greater than a dream.”

The Burden Of Age

“They [elderly people] are a weight and an encumbrance and a mirror of our own mortality. It takes a person of great heart to see past this fact and to see the wisdom the elders have to offer, and to serve them out of gratitude for the life they have passed on to us.”

“But no matter how they make you feel, you should always watch them carefully. They were you and you will be them. You carry the seeds of your old age in you at this very moment, and they hear the echoes of their childhood each time they see you.”

…”they very often fear their own loss of importance. They face the uncertainty of death and are often embittered that the world they worked so hard to create is being discarded by the generations now in power. Their bodies are giving out on them. They increasingly find themselves surrounded only by people their own age, because they know that the young would rather be apart from them. They often live in memories.”

The Burden of Age

“You must remember this: even in their infirmity, elders seek and value their dignity. What they want, above all else, is to feel that their lives are valued, and that their time on earth has not been wasted.”

Masculinity

Norman Mailer, in Christians and Cannibals, made a similar observation: "Masculinity is not something given to you, something you're born with, but something you gain. And you gain it by winning small battles with honor."

Giving

We make a living by what we get, we make a life by what we give. (Winston Churchill)

Optimism – Pessimism (Winston Churchill)

The pessimist sees difficulty in every opportunity. The optimist sees the opportunity in every difficulty.

For myself I am an optimist - it does not seem to be much use being anything else.


Mistakes (Winston Churchill)

If a thing is worth doing, it's worth doing badly.

You will make all kinds of mistakes; but as long as you are generous and true and also fierce you cannot hurt the world or even seriously distress her. She was meant to be wooed and won by youth

Personally I'm always ready to learn, although I do not always like being taught.

Giving up…. (Winston Churchill)

Here is the answer which I will give to President Roosevelt... We shall not fail or falter; we shall not weaken or tire. Neither the sudden shock of battle nor the long-drawn trials of vigilance and exertion will wear us down. Give us the tools and we will finish the job.

Never give in--never, never, never, never, in nothing great or small, large or petty, never give in except to convictions of honour and good sense. Never yield to force; never yield to the apparently overwhelming might of the enemy.

Success (Winston Churchill)

Success is the ability to go from failure to failure without losing your enthusiasm.

Winston Churchill (Misc)

He has all the virtues I dislike and none of the vices I admire.

I have always felt that a politician is to be judged by the animosities he excites among his opponents

The price of greatness is responsibility.

Never hold discussions with the monkey when the organ grinder is in the room.

Courage (Winston Churchill)

Courage is what it takes to stand up and speak.

Courage is also what it takes to sit down and listen.

An appeaser is one who feeds a crocodile - hoping it will eat him last.

Winston Churchill

One ought never to turn one's back on a threatened danger and try to run away from it. If you do that, you will double the danger. But if you meet it promptly and without flinching, you will reduce the danger by half.

This truth is incontrovertible. Panic may resent it; ignorance may deride it; malice may distort it; but there it is.

Kites rise highest against the wind -- not with it.

Seneca

There is nothing in the world so much admired

as a man who knows how to bear unhappiness with courage.

Robert Frost

I shall be telling this with a sigh

Somewhere ages and ages hence:

Two roads diverged in a wood, and I-

I took the one less traveled by,

And that has made all the difference.

Charles Darwin

It is not the strongest of the species that survives, nor the most intelligent; it is the one that is most adaptable to change.

Harry Truman

It is amazing what you can accomplish if you do not care who gets the credit.

If you can't stand the heat, get out of the kitchen.

I have found the best way to give advice to your children is to find out what they want and then advise them to do it.

Doing what is right . . .

Cowardice asks the question - is it safe?

Expediency asks the question - is it politic?

Vanity asks the question - is it popular?

But conscience asks the question - is it right?

And there comes a time when one must take a position that is neither safe, nor politic, nor popular; but one must take it because it is right.

Martin Luther King

Courage

Courage is the power of the mind to overcome fear.

Martin Luther King

Ultimate measure of a man

The ultimate measure of a man is not where he stands in moments of comfort, but where he stands at times of challenge and controversy.

Martin Luther King

Principles

In the end, we will remember not the words of our enemies, but the silence of our friends.

Our lives begin to end the day we become silent about things that matter.

I believe that unarmed truth and unconditional love will have the final word in reality. That is why right, temporarily defeated, is stronger than evil triumphant. Martin Luther King

The measure of a man

The ultimate measure of a man is not where he stands in moments of comfort and convenience, but where he stands at times of challenge and controversy.

If a man hasn't discovered something that he would die for, he isn't fit to live.

Martin Luther King

Enemies


Forgive your enemies, but never forget their names.

John F. Kennedy

Fear

When you get to the end of your rope, tie a knot and hang on.

Men are not prisoners of fate, but only prisoners of their own minds.

First of all, let me assert my firm belief that the only thing we have to fear is fear itself - nameless, unreasoning, unjustified terror which paralyzes needed efforts to convert retreat into advance.

Franklin D. Roosevelt

Future


We cannot always build the future for our youth, but we can build our youth for the future.

The only limit to our realization of tomorrow will be our doubts of today.

Franklin D. Roosevelt

Albert Einstein . . .

Strive not to be a success, but rather to be of value.

The tragedy of life is what dies inside a man while he lives.

Love is a better teacher than duty.

It is only to the individual that a soul is given.

Tuesday, August 28, 2007

My sermon on Restarting Fatherhood . . . .

2007 UUMen Sermon Award Winner

Restarting Fatherhood, My Up-Down Solution

by Frank Mundo

Reading ….

From Forgiving your Father for Fathers Day, By Mark Brandenburg:

The memory of my father stays with me like a shadow.

It’s a shadow filled with a complex array of gratitude, sadness, disappointment, and awe. It is the same for all men, for there’s no escaping these memories. They are deeply imbedded in us, and they impact us every day of our lives.

And whether you’re trying to live up to your father’s expectations, prove him wrong, or rid your memory of him, the shadow of your father will remain. Each effort demands its’ own cost. And each effort will keep the shadow close to you.

When you have children, the memories of your father grow stronger. The wounds that haven’t healed are poised to be inflicted on them. We all carry wounds from our father. We all feel the pain of not “measuring up” in some way. But whatever your wounds, it’s important to remember this: What is not healed in you will show up in your children. It will show up no matter how hard you fight against it, and no matter how hard you try “not to be your father.” It will show up, and transcend all your efforts to prevent it.

What’s left to us is a simple choice. Would we like to live with these wounds, and transfer them to our sons and daughters, or would we like to explore them, and find a way to heal them? To be an effective father is to understand the power of the memories you make with your child each day. These memories can be touched by the wounds from your childhood, or they can be touched by forgiveness and love. And while the path to forgiveness can be difficult, it’s worth every ounce of effort you give it. And most importantly, it is a gift to your children, and the generations that follow them. (1)


* * * *

Let me start with a short piece written by Ken Druck, author of The Secrets Men Keep:

“When my Uncle Nathan was 70, he visited his father’s grave tucked away in a corner of a cemetery in the Bronx. He stood there facing the headstone, the November wind ruffling his silver hair. Suddenly, his body started shaking. Tears streaked his face. “Dad, you never even put your arms around me,” he sobbed, spilling out a secret grief that he had carried around with him all these years. “You never touched me. You never hugged me. Where were you when I needed you?

It may surprise us to know that the most powerful common denominator influencing men’s lives today is the relationship we had with our fathers. The events and circumstances may have taken place years, even decades, ago. They may appear irrelevant to our lives in the present. But if we look beyond the surface, we will discover, as my Uncle Nathan did, that Dad is still very much with us today. Much of our behavior and many of our attitudes toward living can be traced to our fathers. Whether our dad was physically or psychologically absent, whether he died when we were young or is still alive at a ripe old age, whether we consider him a good father or a poor one, our fathers are in us. Every man hears the silent voice of his father inside his own head.

One of the most important clues to discovering who we really are lies in knowing who we were in relation to our fathers. One of the best-kept secrets for many men is the extent to which they allow themselves to be tied to their fathers, dead or alive.

…… our stories uncover a deep yearning for Father’s love and acceptance.

And some, like my Uncle Nathan, will journey to their own graves with that secret longing unsatisfied…”(2)

How do we mend ourselves with our fathers… and mend our sons and daughters with ourselves?

What about my father?

My father was a physicist. During WWII he was swept off a Radar Mast of an American Destroyer in mid Atlantic and was lucky enough to be plucked out of the sea by a sailor tied by a lifeline to a following British Destroyer. Later my father participated in the war by getting American planes filled with bombs into the air and then bailing out so they could flown by radio control to Germany to blow up submarines in their bunkers. Joe Kennedy was in my father’s group. He didn’t make it out of his plane. There is my awe.

During my younger years my father designed guidance systems for Intercontinental Ballistic Missiles. In his work he was rarely home. But he provided for us, we had what we needed but rarely saw him…. with his travels, working late at night and on weekends. We never wanted for anything… in a material sense. There is my gratitude.

He was never there at any significant event in my life that I can remember… he was somewhat like the Lone Ranger… always riding in and out of town. Like many men of his generation… “he wanted to raise us but [it seemed] he didn’t want to know us.” There is my sadness and my disappointment.

I never understood my father’s work. I was never introduced to it. I feared it. Would I be lost at sea… or disappear from my family when I became a man, and began to work?

I recall the cold shock of horror I received… like nothing I had ever felt before… when, as a child I saw the movie, Moby Dick. You will recall from that story… that Captain Ahab had a fury and an obsession with catching the White Whale… Moby Dick… the whale that had bitten off one of his legs. He pursued the whale relentlessly across several oceans and finally, when he did come upon the whale at last he jumped into a whaleboat and harpooned the whale. As the harpoon rope raced out he got caught in the rope and was pulled over the side. The next scene – and the one that struck horror in my heart… was the shot of Captain Ahab’s body, lashed to the side of the whale as it surfaced and then sank under the waves.. Ahab’s lifeless arm swinging back and forth. A “symbolic” last farewell….

For years I had thought that the horror I experienced in that movie – and it was truly visceral - was based on an unconscious recognition of the consequences of uncontrolled anger. However, in preparing this sermon I have come to an entirely different awareness. Ahab was very likely my father ... and his predicament … one that lay in wait for me were I to become passionately committed to work.

What was it that I expected to get from my father that I didn’t get? Was it hugs? Was it his presence at my games and plays or recognition of me as a person? Edward Frost puts this question felt by so many men… better than I…..

“What is it about fathers that has them brought so often and kept so late in the court of their children’s judgment? … What is it about the task of fathering so many fumble with and finally put aside?(3)”

When I became a father I promised myself to be more involved with my children... and for a time, it worked. I raced to daycare. I took time off for birthday parties. I went to school events and games. I sat in bed with my youngest son and read him stories. We had a favorite book on dogs. All kinds of dogs. He could recognize and name them all.

I must tell you about one of those “moments” that a parent has, which will always bring a smile to my lips. We were in the park, and I was pushing my son along in his stroller. A middle-aged lady came along with a small dog on a leash. Seeing Frank Jr. she knelt down, scooped up her dog and presented it him. “See, she said, “…doggie”. My son gently patted the dog on the head, then looked the lady square in the eye and uttered a single word. “Chihuahua.”

My other son… I used to put him in a waste basket and fly him around the house – he holding on to the edge for dear life… and I… well making airplane noises while we buzzed by wing chairs and over ottomans. Cherished memories…

As my children grew older, I grew less and less able to be a part of their lives. Divorce was part of the equation. But an equally large part is that I never had had any experiences of son-to-father. I didn’t really know how to relate. I didn’t know how to be involved… and perhaps worse yet…. I didn’t sense the loss of what I really didn’t have before… from the son side of the equation. Indeed it wasn’t until I arrived at being older that I was suddenly struck with the profound sense of loss of shared experiences … experiences that never were and which will never be.

Thinking again about my father…. and what I had missed…. I recalled an Edward Frost sermon. I wrote to him for the text…

What did I expect from my father, I wonder? What was it I so desperately needed, after it was too late, after he could no longer give it? Robert Bly… said what boys and young men need from older men is blessing -- because too few are blessed by their fathers. Blessing is the bestowal of approval and encouragement. "Blessing," says Webster’s Dictionary, "is a thing conducive to happiness and welfare." And without the blessing of the father all else, it seems, fails to be conducive to happiness or welfare.

For some of us, it seems, without the father’s blessing, his approval and encouragement, nothing fully satisfies. Always there is the rising urge to take the small or large success and burst with it through memory’s door shouting, "Hey, Dad, guess what?" And if he is not home, or occupied with his failings, or deep in his despair, his hopeless anger, his envy of his children, where, then, shall we go for blessing? (3).

I came to realize I had stumbled on the source of the profound sense of loss and sadness I had in my life. I wondered if other men felt it. I sought out their counsel, their wisdom and, finding many with similar backgrounds and stories, experienced their grief. Out of that I came to realize that fathering is an inter-generational thing. It doesn’t get fixed so easily in a single generation. What is needed is what I came to call an “Up-Down Solution.”

The “Up” part is fixing yourself and your relationship with your own father …with forgiveness. Returning to thoughts of Mark Brandenburg, who wrote the words of our reading this morning….

Forgiveness can be a powerful and transforming experience. It is a way of giving up hope that the past can be changed. When you forgive your father, you accept the past as it was, and ready yourself to move forward. No matter how abusive or absent your father was, you accept what happened, and stop blaming your father for your current problems.

Forgiveness is not a one-time event. It happens emotionally when we feel the pain and sadness from letting go of a better past, and what we might have had. It happens when we stop blaming our fathers, and stop using anger to shield us from our sadness.

Forgiveness happens in our thoughts when we see our fathers for who they were, and not for whom we wanted them to be. It happens when we end the illusion of the selfless father, who looks after our needs first and foremost.

Forgiveness is complete when we allow it to unfold. It is a process, and it may take years. But as each layer of anger peels away, your opportunities expand. The energy that was devoted to anger and regret can now be devoted to things that matter: passion, truth, and love…[ and being a better father]. (1)

The other part of forgiveness is to try to forgive yourself. To help with this I would offer you a poem written by David Ray. It’s called "Thanks, Robert Frost."

Do you have hope for the future?
Someone asked Robert Frost, toward the end.

Yes, and even for the past, he replied,
that it will turn out to have been all right for what it was.


Something we can accept,
mistakes made by the selves we had to be,
not able to be, perhaps, what we wished,
or what looking back half the time
it seems we could so easily have been, or ought...

The future, yes, and even for the past,
that it will become something we can bear.
And I too, and my children, so I hope…
will recall as not too heavy the tug of those albatrosses
I sadly placed upon their tender necks.


Hope for the past, yes, old Frost,
your words provide that courage
and it brings strange peace that itself passes into past,
easier to bear because you said it, rather casually,
as snow went on falling in Vermont years ago
.

The “Down” part of the solution is to bless your children. It could be as simple as a phone call this afternoon. Call your children and tell them how much their life has meant to you and that you are proud of them. Recognize and honor the choices they have made if you can. If you can only acknowledge their choices, do that and speak to them of how their “being” has added to your life.

Speak to them of the time they were in the stroller and knocked some lady on her keister with their juvenile brilliance.

It is quite likely, when you’re pushing up daisies, they’ll remember your phone call. Maybe even make one of their own….


* * * *

(1) Mark Brandenburg, Forgiving your Father for Fathers Day

(2) Ken Druck, The Secrets Men Keep

(3) Edward Frost, sermon: Life with Father

Monday, August 27, 2007

Men's Network Male Involvement in Church

UU Men's Network – UU Church, Male involvement

Are we losing our men, and if so, why? Church after church reports that roughly two thirds of new members are women, and nominating committees report that men are more difficult to drag on into serving positions of leadership. More men fail to serve out their terms of service, for whatever reason, and men report, often sheepishly and occasionally with surprise, that they're feeling excluded from decision making and the object of "politically incorrect" gender bashing. A panel of UUMeN members and one woman minister gathered to discuss the causes and solutions to these problems. Jaco ten Hove of UUMeN moderated a panel consisting of Dick Michaels, Abhi Janamanchi, Carol Rosine, and Tom Owen-Towle.

Dick Michaels asked, "In a world when the role of men is changing and in many ways being devalued, what is the role for men? The dilemma for men is particularly poignant. Men tend to disengage, and so our congregations become less and less male." He then wondered whether our problem resides in our inability to frame our existential questions in terms of anything but disengagement or the "competitive society."

Abhi Janamanchi, the minister of the Unitarian Universalist Church of Sarasota, reported that in his church, two thirds of new members are women, and there are more women than men in leadership positions. His nominating committees report more difficulty getting men to volunteer than women and that they tended to resign prematurely. Many of the men stated they had held leadership positions all their lives and just wanted to be and come to church and "help out" now they are retired. Still, Janamanchi wondered if the reasons were deeper. In another church men reported feeling excluded and solutions they presented were characterized as "Oh, that's typically male!" Perhaps we have redefined who we are to eliminate patriarchy. Our test is the number of women, but we have not redefined that space to honor men.

Carol Rosine is minister of First Universalist of Franklin, MA, which grew from 20 over 400 members under her leadership. She reported that men had been watching the women who were deeply and enthusiastically involved in "Cakes for the Queen of Heaven" and other feminist programs. The men wondered if women were more emotional or spiritual than men, but finally decided that it was up to them to find their authentic voices. Rosine, though a feminist, knew she had to minister to both men and women, but she was puzzle how to reach them. The men's group experienced several false starts and usually fizzled out after a few months. The key event was that "Men With Tool Belts" rebuilt a house on property the church owned, and this experience was the basis of a renewed and finally successful group. Finally, she began to meet with them for two hours a meeting. They began by talking to her about what was it like to grow up as a boy, what they worried about and other issues that generally are taboo among men. The men in the Franklin congregation wanted her to know there are different sides to being a man. There is a playful side involving sports and competition and "potato cannons." There also is a side that longs for relationship and to nurture and be nurtured. In most places in their lives it is safer to keep a lid on their emotions and not to make themselves vulnerable. In the process of talking to her, they began to talk to each other and discovered the church is a safe place to expose their longings and vulnerabilities. They also learned the importance men play in the lives of boys and in their becoming men. They found a way to achieve all these goals in a satisfying and meaningful way that did not challenge their images of themselves as men.

Tom Owen-Towle, the outgoing president of UUMeN, is co-minister of the First Unitarian Universalist Church of San Diego, CA and a long-term leader of the men's movement in Unitarian Universalism. He said the future needs to be different from the past. He sees the challenge as needing to create a culture that is male enhancing and affirms masculine energy and gifts, but that does not accept that dominance at the expense of others is a necessary part of maleness or of masculinity. He also stated that no man or boy should have to look outside of his own church to find support.

In the audience participation, some disagreement emerged, particularly with the role of feminism in UUMeN, but there was general agreement that men were not entirely pleased with the new world. One participant saw that "matriarchy" was generally viewed as always positive and nurturing, while "patriarchy" generally was viewed as negative and isolating. Another reported that he didn't view all men as potential rapists. One man emphasized that most sexual violence actually occurred in prisons and was against other men. Others agreed that perhaps men felt a sense of loss, since they were having to move back from the table to make room for women, but that women were experiencing exhilaration in finding full humanity.

From the animated looks on the faces of the participants, and from the continuing knots of men talking as they departed the room, they enjoyed the discussions.

Reported for the Web by Bob Hurst

Sunday, August 26, 2007

Oh Brother Where Art Thou ?

O Brother, Where Art Thou?

An essay by the Reverend Kenneth S. Beldon

Published in the Fall, 2001 issue of

UU Voice, An Independent Journal of News and Opinion

The scene is by now familiar to me, although, even in the midst of joy, it is somewhat dispiriting. Another new member Sunday: our membership book is opened once more to receive the signatures of the new people who desire to join our liberal religious community. The names of the new members are read aloud. They come forward to the front of our sanctuary to sign their names and to receive a flower and a packet containing introductory information about our congregation. They are welcomed by both myself and representatives of the Board. After each person signs the book, they remain standing near the pulpit with the other new members. When all the names have been read, the congregation stands and reads together a covenant of welcome and affirmation to the new folks. The assembled worshippers applaud, and then, the ritual concluded, everyone takes their seats.

Glad tidings and good feelings abound on the day that we welcome newcomers to our congregation. We all partake in the excitement that comes from knowing that our faith is being shared among a greater number of souls. And yet, I can’t help feeling that there’s a pattern emerging during the several years that our new congregation has been welcoming new members: a subtle indication that our liberal religious community may not be reaching a group of people in need of the liberating message that Unitarian Universalism has to offer. When I look at our membership roster, when I try and track attendance and participation in our congregation, I arrive at this question: Where, I wonder, are all the men?

The relative scarcity of men in my congregation is evident not only on Sunday morning. It can be perceived when our committees gather, when religious education classes meet, when social events bring us together simply for the sake of shared time. When I examined the visitor’s book for the last six months, women outnumbered men by a substantial margin. The concern for gender equity is preeminent when our nominating committee considers names for Board positions: are there enough men willing to serve so that there might be equal numbers of male and female?

Such issues are not limited to my congregation alone. A panel discussion at the General Assembly just passed in Cleveland wondered aloud about the status of men within our religious movement by asking the question, "Is There a Future for Men in Unitarian Universalism?" It was reported that nearly two thirds of new members in many of our congregations are women, and that congregations are often hard pressed in finding men to serve in positions of leadership. We also know that a clear majority of the people now informational and seminary training for the ministry are women. Over half the ministers in our denomination are women. Women, it seems, are stepping up to the call to service in our congregations, while men, it appears, are stepping out. To say it plainly: we don’t need fewer women, we do need more men.

The various feminist and women’s rights movements in the history of our country have affected our association more profoundly than any other American denomination. This ought to be a cause for unequivocal celebration for men, not just for women. It would be an overstatement to say that there are as many varieties of feminism as there are women, but feminism cannot be seen as monolith, asserting only one ideology or view about the status of women. There are certainly varieties of feminist thought that diminish, if not demean, the experience of men, and doubtless some of these ideas are found in our churches, operating in such a way to make some men feel unwelcome and unwanted. But, as a man and a minister I can say that I have found male bashing to be extremely rare and it is usually bound up with other issues regarding the use and abuse of power within our congregations.

The practical commitment to feminism I’ve most often witnessed in our churches is similar to how my ethics professor, a Catholic Sister of Mercy, in divinity school defined the word. She said that feminism was a belief in equality and mutuality between the sexes grounded primarily, but not exclusively, in women’s experiences and was also committed to the flourishing of all human beings. The concern for the flourishing, the full development of the potentiality in all our lives, male and female, can be said to be rightfully the aim and goal of our liberal religious movement. At their best, our congregations aid in the cultivation of our gifts, our strengths, our healing, and our ministries. With its concern for wholeness and a commitment to standing against all those elements in our common existence that inhibit and destroy the fullness of lives, feminism provides us a vision of our communities as places wherein lives are transformed. Such a promise is not limited to women, but exists as a challenge to men to find fullness in our lives as well. Such an opportunity may be daunting to many men who are used to patterns of relationship that are circumscribed within the set patterns of "male experience." I fear that the men most in need of healing and supportive community in our congregations are the ones least able to communicate their needs about how congregational life can be relevant to their lives.

In the first year of my ministry, there was a young couple in the congregation that has since left the church. They were having financial difficulties, problems with chemical dependencies. Their marriage was failing and they would be splitting up in the near future and leaving the area, going their separate ways. I knew all this from the woman in the relationship. We talked regularly as she made her plans to leave. Although she knew that what she wanted was to get out, she also worried about her estranged husband, his lack of community, and social isolation. I resisted calling him for some time, figuring that he would call me when he was ready. Finally, just a few days before he was to leave town, I contacted him, and we met that afternoon.

When he arrived at my office, he was clearly on edge. His self-esteem was shaken. When he spoke he rarely looked at me, his eyes rimmed with the redness that came from consistent tears. He shared his story, punctuated with sobs. As I listened I realized that he and I shared some commonalities.

We were both the same age and both went to established northeastern prep schools, separated by less than a hundred miles. He was clearly a jock in high school, the kind of fellow student around whom I felt nakedly inferior, covetous of what I believed to be his self confidence, contemptuous of the apparent ease with which he roamed the campus and commanded attention while I nervously attempted not to be noticed.

Yet, here he was, barely a decade after prep school, weeping in my office about his failed career, poor financial choices, and his inability to save his marriage. He was no longer the young man whom I would have so arrogantly and enviously judged in high school. He was now just a broken man, shuffling about in the shattered pieces of his life. On the other hand, the woman, now his ex-wife, was able to reach out to me, to other people in the church, able to speak of her pain and also to start to plan her life as it would be after they split. He left town, his pain barely known to anyone in the congregation and barely communicated to me. I think of him often. I wonder what more the congregation could have offered him. I know that I could have offered him more of my time, more of my presence, but instead assumed he would take the initiative if he wanted to talk. How easily I fell into a conditioned response to engage in an emotional laissez faire. Our nascent men’s group was not in existence at that time. In his silence, he suffered alone.

The social critic Stanley Aronowitz has written: "One point to be made is the extent to which men become victims of the emotional plague of always having to be in control; how much we are deprived of genuine recognition not only by our mates, but also by our children. Male power comes at the price of emotional isolation."

Aronowitz’s message is that traditional ideas about masculinity construct the need for power and control over one’s life and emotions by restraining the need for being close to others. Being in true relationship with another person, or to ourselves, means that we must be willing to risk, to let our guard down and venture into emotional or relational terrain where asserting unilateral control can only be a bar to authentic self realization or disclosure. Under traditionally masculine terms, the extent to which one is vulnerable is seen as an index of inauthentic male experience. Because of this, many men, especially straight men, avoid being vulnerable, as we are not often rewarded and more than infrequently chided for such behavior. The primary male virtue has been traditionally regarded as strength, albeit an emotionally truncated, self-sufficient one, and the primary male vice has been perceived weakness or being "soft".

Although the incident occurred nearly three decades ago, we can remember Edmund Muskie crying on the campaign trail in 1972 as an example of a man who very publicly transgressed the norms of supposed real manhood. His perceived sin was that he sought psychological counseling. In both seeking support and then in his reaction to its being made public, Muskie violated two of the key rules without which traditional conceptions of masculinity stand: not being self sufficient enough to solve his problems on his own and then expressing his pain in plain sight through his tears because, of course, boys (and by extension, men) do not cry. But, of course, boys and men do cry and the question is whether our congregations are safe places for men to express the whole of themselves and the holes within themselves.

However we define that overused word, spirituality, it consists in part of our response to this question: how do we live in the presence of the unbidden in our lives, the grace or the sorrow that visits us not through the mechanism of our control or our strivings, but simply through our being alive? As our congregations become places where not only reason and rationality are enshrined as our birthright, men, who are more conditioned to focus on what we can control, are often left behind. We need a language of male relationship to self and other that speaks of our ability to receive from life, and from each other, without it be construed, or felt, as weakness or passivity.

Even as some aspects of patriarchy are no longer as powerful in our society, the cultural attitudes of many men still retain some of the traditional, sexist ideas concerning the proper role of men in relation to women, other men, and their own selves. Within the past decade we have seen religiously affiliated mass mobilizations of men in the form of the Promise Keepers and the Nation of Islam’s Million Man March. Whatever the important differences between these groups are, their affinities are telling. With both groups the rhetoric of male responsibility is established as part of a response to what Barbara Ehrenreich calls the male "flight from women." To counter this flight, (which is perceived as a double departure from the traditional male roles of protector and provider), the man is urged to atone, (re)assume the role of the head of the household, and return to his position as guarantor of the well being of his "dependents."

Such language is highly problematic when examined from a perspective that seeks to posit equality and mutuality as the ideal in gender and sexual relations. Not only is such language deeply homophobic, for it presupposes heterosexuality as the absolute norm, but it assumes that male supremacy and a hierarchical ordering of gender relations are natural and inextricably embedded in nature or God’s law. In the view of such traditionalists, men are not so much estranged from women as they are from their realization of the (divinely ordained) law. In this view, straight men occupy the top human rung of the great chain of being. Such was the language affirmed by the Southern Baptist Convention a few years back, when it called for wives to submit gracefully to their husbands.

Our Unitarian Universalist tradition calls men into a much more nuanced conversation about the meaning of being a man: one that wants to celebrate and affirm the varieties of men’s experiences while also insisting that such valuing occur in the context of religious community that refuses to privilege male lives over female lives. Being a man in this environment is not always easy. Especially for men of a certain age or generation, men who may not have been raised by feminist moms or in homes where power and decision making was shared equally between the sexes, or who have worked in environments where men did one type of work and women another type, such men have seen many of the changes in broader society reflected, often more intensely, in the life of our churches.

In response, some men have retreated from the lives of their churches out of the misguided, but understandable, notion that the only way to share power with women was to hands over the reigns and step out of the way. While perhaps motivated by a desire not to impede progress, such steps can also be a simultaneously retreat from church life, a belief that "it’s not really my church". Acts motivated by such thinking can only mean that there are more men who are less personally invested in the lives of their churches, giving less to them and getting far less from them. We are called to engage in the life our churches, even when we might be challenged, rather than slip quietly away from them.

There are other men who, seeing the various ways in which women’s history and identity is celebrated in our congregations, feel as if they are being left out and desire men’s experience to receive the same sort of validation. As I overhead a man once say at a UU conference, "If there’s a women’s history month, shouldn’t we have a men’s history month as well?" While such questions seem to aim at equality in form, they elide the very real history of male power and privilege, both in the religious and secular worlds. As UU men we need to be honest about the inequalities that are a part of our common inheritance and recognize the corrective differences that are undertaken to uncover and uplift aspects of our heritage that misogyny and sexism derided or helped to render invisible. The time when men’s experiences were taken to be normative for all is a world well lost. We are called to a prophetic, not a reactionary, masculinity that does not begrudge women when their voices are sometimes heard louder than our own. We have more important work to do than feeling as if we are in constant competition to get our message, the value of our own lives, out there.

When I picture what men need more than anything else in our congregational life, I think of an exercise that some of our congregations use to help in the process of discerning individual gifts and ministries. A box is divided into four quadrants, on the vertical axis lies these words, one written on top of the other: like/don’t like; on the horizontal axis lies these words: one written next to the other: good at/not good at. A person fills them in according to which box dictates which combination. With the idea that we all bring gifts to our religious communities, and also aspects of ourselves that we would like to have augmented, the boxes are a diagnostic tool. Often the most important box for people is the one that combines those skills that a person likes with the self perception that greater proficiency is desired in those areas. If what lies in there for many men is a greater need for self-revelation and authentic relationship with ourselves and others, then this box holds the beginnings of the map to wholeness. Only by being fully present to ourselves, even in understanding that what and who we love is often not within our control, then we might come to find ourselves and begin to make a home in our houses of worship.