Search This Blog

Friday, August 10, 2007

The Fathers I Found in the Woods - Davidson

The Fathers I Found in the Woods

As Father's Day approaches, I am reminded yet again that I grew up without a dad and how difficult that has been. Each year, Father's Day has been a reminder to me of all that I missed. This year, however, will be different. As a forty-two year old man, I will celebrate my relationship to the men I have come to know through the men's movement. This year, I will pay homage to those who have mentored and guided me, who gave me their shoulders to lean on; they fathered me and brothered me, and introduced me to the men's work that has helped me recover and move on.

My parents split up before I was born and I was raised by my mother, a government secretary, along with my three sisters in the Riggs Park section of northeast D.C. Throughout my childhood, I saw my father a half dozen times, and then only for the few minutes when he would appear to hand my mother an intermittent alimony and child support payment. In my young child's way, I wrote often to him, pleading with him to come back. He never answered my letters. Amazingly, my mother never consciously tried to make me dislike my father. Her willingness to see the best side of things has helped me to persevere, through occasional calls and visits, to try and get to know my father.

It left me with a sad vacancy that he had shared so little of his life. He never appeared to be a mean person. I constantly ruminated on who he was and why we were seperated: "He must have left because I was one child too many," was one. Another was, "Dad can't stand relatives." I made countless drawings of how I imagined my father fighting in WWII and Korea. Sometimes I wished he had died in the war so that I could draw some plausible conclusion.

Only when I had grown up did I learn from other people that he had been the army inspector general for those MASH units that the Korean War period TV show was about. He designed a complete dental office that fit in the back of a truck, so that even the soldiers in the front lines could be seen by a dentist. A distant relative sent me a magazine article about his success as a bridge player.

I did not do well with the few male teachers I had all the way through school. I witnessed my high school P.E. teacher strike a boy hard, shoving his head into a tile wall for not responding to an order fast enough. The music teacher was unpredictable as to whether he would praise or chastise you in front of the class. These men terrified me and I felt their scorn for my not being so eager to trust them. I often found myself crossing the unspoken boundaries of maleness. I was much more comfortable playing with the girls during free time. When other boys threatened me, I refused to fight with them (which to my surprise, only made them angrier rather than feel victorious).

While out dancing with friends in college, I wondered at how men and women could hug each other, even where no sexual relationship existed, or was neccesarily desired. The women did the same between themselves, but none of the men hugged another man. I decided that if hugging was about affection, not sex, I was going to start hugging the men, too.

I spent my twenties and thirties as an artist, struggling through my paintings to make sense of my father's abandonment. In one work, painted in furtive cross-hatched strokes, I depicted myself with outstretched arms and legs running across a barren landscape. My figure, like the painful longing I had in those days, fills the whole foreground, my head is turned to see my father descending a hill towards me. Like some prehistoric cave painter, I hoped that by means of capturing my desire for reconciliation with my father on canvas, the event itself would certainly come true. In parallel, my early adult years were filled with bouncing from one unrewarding job to another just to get by, and a succession of relationships with women who feared my neediness. Maybe the proviso deep down was, if I could make those impossible situations work, I had a chance to get the really impossible thing I wanted, the love and approval of my father.

By being a working artist I began to live in the world of men who I had more in common with. I shared my first apartment with Jon, a folk musician two years younger than me, who became the brother I never had. He had a wonderful way of never letting a dispute come between us. He always hung in there with me until it was settled. Jon shared all his secrets and was interested in mine, reassuring me when I became depressed or had a hard time understanding him. He would pose for me while playing his mandolin. In these gentle ways, he helped me begin to overcome my fear of being unacceptable to my fellow man.

It was with Jon's encouragement that I began to see a therapist. After many years of treatment I came to understand my father had not rejected me, but that he was a damaged person incapable of demonstrating affection and to whom deep communication and commitment was just too painful. This framework for his actions did not take away the pain I felt. How he got to be this way, I will most likely never know. Somewhere along the line something happened to him that made the price of intimacy too expensive. Despite my many attempts at appealing to him through his interests, such as playing bridge and his army days, he still refused to let down his guard with me. Our relationship remained entirely on his terms.

Towards the end of my therapy, my psychologist encouraged me to get involved with the men's movement as a means of bringing more active, positive relationships with older men into my life. She told me that I did not have to be trapped in the "emotional disability" that my father had imparted to me. I could go on to experience manhood as both powerful and warm. I was still skeptical that I could find many men as thoroughly insightful and caring as her, but my need out-weighed the risk of disapointment.

With curiosity I accepted a new friend's invitation to go with him to the Buffalo Gap Men's Retreat on Columbus Day weekend. Having sent in our $140 fees to the Men's Council of Washington, the non-profit sponsor, we drove through the stunningly beautiful autumn landscape, and arrived in Capon Bridge, West Virginia, two hours west of D.C. The schedule of workshops and events began that evening with a greeting ritual. All one-hundred and fifty-plus participants formed a circle in order of age. Each man greeted those older than himself, and then took his place to be greeted by his youngers. The greeting varied from eye contact, or hugs to a touch of the hand on the heart. The youngers acknowledged with deep respect the elders and the elders gave their blessing. I gave and received from my elders the warm and encouraging hugs I have never gotten from my father.

Men of all ages, boys and teenagers, too, were there. Other married men, singles, gays, blue collar workers from central Virgina, the lawyers and doctors from Bethesda, clerics and clinical social workers, men in the military, blacks and whites from the shy to the effusive, engaged each other with compassion and concern. I even saw an artist from D.C. I knew. This was not so easy for me. I kept thinking, "If only I could have had something like this ten, twenty years before, how less complex getting to know men would have been by now." I found out as the retreat progressed that this was a new experience for many of us.

The next morning, I walked up an open field and into a grove of cedars where the "Finding Your Inner Voice" workshop had already begun. The leader smiled as he welcomed me to join the others. His chopped salt and pepper hair and thin crinkled face beamed a reassuring blend of concern and delight. "Try just singing your name, any old way," he drawled with a soft gravelly pitch. One guy in casual dress slacks and penny-loafers and another with no clothes on at all were laughing at themselves as they each came up with very original tunes. By the end of the workshop I felt an unstoppable grin spread across my face as all our voices came together as one, under our leader's tutelage.

The sweat lodge, an introduction to the Lakota ritual of purification, was probably the most popular activity. The steam-filled tent made of old blankets and bits of blue plastic tarpelin was tightly packed with sweating bodies in bathing suits, in bathrobes or just plain naked. It was a much more solemn affair than I expected, with the ritual leader or "water pourer" quite strict and the heat difficult to stand. When some of the men started to spontaneously hum or "om", he gave the crowd an extended lecture on how, "you shouldn't mix medicines," I am sure he was right given the tradition he was representing, but he reminded me too much of a rule-bound father. With absolutely no light, save for glow of the hot rocks in a central pit, I could not see the leader that I then chose to have some words with. Months later I called an acquaintance I had not seen since college, whose name I saw on the list of participants. Upon asking why I had not recognized him anywhere, he said that all he did at Buffalo Gap was run the sweat lodge. "So your the guy that was so pendantic," I chided. "So your the jerk who argued with me!" he responded. We had a laugh and agreed to disagree.

As a sometime conga drummer, I enjoyed more the drumming sessions in the open pavilion, and the chance for rhythmic union with drummers far better than I.

Over the course of the weekend, I listened to other men's stories, especially those who had been to Buffalo Gap before. An older man, from Richmond, told me, "When I go into my feelings here, I'm not rejected or made fun of. Everyone listens in accepting silence, not trying to block me because of their own fears. You get respect for what you have to say." A middle-aged man from Takoma Park spoke to me of his need to "face my fear of all that I have missed by not showing up for life." I felt honored to share in such a revelation, and wished that my father would acknowledge such thoughts.

That evening, with mugs of hot coffee in hand, the friend who I had come with and I walked outside the camp and up the hill and into the woods that surrounded us, to get a better view of the bonfire ritual below, the final event of the weekend. From this darkened height I could see the thirty-foot flames illuminating the large swirl of men dancing and skipping counterclockwise around its base. Their arms swinging wildly about, all seeming to scream in unison some sort of guttural chant. These are the things that make some people I have met or seen in the media say are weird or silly. I found this event to be a passionate culmination of newly-forged bonds.The strange song the mass of men were emoting was mournful of our losses, but it was also exulting in our liberation. Many shook rattles that they had made at the "Ritual Object Workshop." Some wore the fierce beaked masks they had painted with blotches of red, yellow and black and festooned with feathers and bits of stone for teeth. The drumming echoed up to us in waves that alternately droned and thundered on and on. "Go forth and make a joyful noise unto the lord" came to my mind, as I went down to join them.

By Sunday, I could see clearly what happens when we men gathered to put aside what status we possessed in the world, and joined to help each other's personal growth and spiritual development. It was a great relief to find meaningful commonality and friendship in an environment free of the drinking, bars and sports triad that so typifies most American men's sense of camaraderie. I needed a more thoughtful environment for my male bonding.

As the music and reverie was replaced by the sound of guys packing their belongings, I wondered what changes of spirit we would take home with us. I sauntered down to the site of the still smoldering ashes of the bonfire. A few of the younger men and teenagers were still milling about, poking at the embers with long sticks. None of them wanted to leave.

At Buffalo Gap and in the subsequent monthly Men's Council meetings I joined back in D.C., I found that thoughtful environment. I listened to the stories other men told about their dads, and that many of those at-home-dads were as emotionally removed as mine. Their stories made me feel lucky. I had already overcome some of my earlier hurdles, had managed to meet and marry the woman of my dreams, to sustain a successful marriage and to build a second career for myself doing home repairs.

My journey--transforming my life--is not over yet, . But I have found the means to continue the process.By being involved with the men's movement I have found a place to get some of what I can not get from my father, to dissipate the anger and ambivalence I feel toward him, and to better accept the limitations he places on our relationship. Recently, he called and asked me to do up a genealogy chart for his side of the family. I will be bringing it out when I go to visit later this year. I doubt that we will have the heart-to-heart talk I have always wanted, but regardless of his response, I know it is okay for me to want it. At least I have achieved getting him to like trading hugs with me. I can now take joy in some of the ways that I am like him: the sound of my voice, the way I use my hands, the wrinkles that are forming on my face. I have freed myself to move on to be mentored by older men, and to father those who are younger and in need

Thursday, August 9, 2007

Gatherings book... worth a look

Gatherings

Small Group Ministry for Men

Tony Bushman and Bill Hamilton-Holway

In the Evensong tradition of covenant group ministry, Gatherings offers men the opportunity to grow spiritually and personally by meeting together in an atmosphere of appreciation, attentive listening and self-discovery. The sessions are 120 minutes long and include songs, readings and time for sharing. With space for writing and drawing, the book is designed so that each participant can have his own copy.

The eight services are: Getting to Know One Another; What It Means to Be Male; Friendship; Partnership and Competition; Getting Centered and Balanced; Making Amends; Family and Work; Passion and Loving Relationships.

Tony Bushman is professor emeritus at San Francisco State University and has a master of divinity from Starr King School for the Ministry. He has led men’s groups for over twenty-five years and has developed more than one hundred workshops. Bill Hamilton-Holway is co-minister at the Unitarian Universalist Church in Berkeley, California. He graduated from Meadville Lombard Theological School and has organized men’s groups in congregations in Utah and California.

Praise for Gatherings:

"Gatherings is a much-needed, long-awaited and tremendously valuable resource for Unitarian Universalist men. It will help men of all ages reconnect with one another and themselves."
—Neil Chethik, author, VoiceMale: What Husbands Really Think About Their Marriages, Their Wives, Sex, Housework, and Commitment

"Feeding the souls of men is a crucial concern in Unitarian Universalist congregational life. Bushman and Hamilton-Holway know this and have furnished varied and tasty fare. A small-group ministry geared toward assuaging men's deeper hungers will strengthen our entire liberal religious enterprise. Everyone and everything benefits when our men are properly nourished, and Gatherings does just that."
—Tom Owen-Towle, author, Save the Males: Changing Men...Changing the World

Tuesday, August 7, 2007

Topics for Discussion in Men's Group

POSSIBLE DISCUSSION TOPICS FOR A MEN’S GROUP

What is success ?

What is my mission in life?

What does the term "A good father" mean?

What being a man means in 2007

Leaving… and death

Defining ourselves apart from our work, redefining ourselves as being more than our work.

Dealing with uncertain expectation of our changing cultural context …

Coming into “authentic power” as a man

Being better fathers.

Living with our loneliness and sense of separation – the male lone-wolf syndrome…..

Keeping perspective; keeping a sense of humor.

Finding mentors, role models and being one

Developing intimacy in our lives

Learning how to share feelings

Not being dominant or submissive in our lives, achieving balance of strength & vulnerability

Maintaining our pride of men while we affirm the importance of feminism

Nurturing our relations with spouses, lovers, children, fathers, mothers and friends

Developing a more in depth understanding of our relationships with women

Confronting men’s violence towards women (and other men) as men & not leaving to women

Converting our own rage and violence into a constructive force

Focusing on the need for health and self-care.

Working to develop an inclusive men’s movement: older-younger, disabled, interracial

When was the first time you thought that someone saw you as a man ?

Who has been a model for you, about good manhood?

Part of being an American man means carrying certain burdens. What is the burden you

would most like to lay down?

What was it like to grow up as a boy

The importance men play in the lives of boys

Sunday, August 5, 2007

On Fathers . . .

ON FATHERS . . .

Finding our Fathers … Samuel Osherson Notes...


Until a man “names his father,” sees him clearly as who he is and was, it is that much more difficult for him to grow up himself and become a father to his children, a husband to a wife, or a mentor to the younger generation at work. That is every man’s task of healing the wounded father within.”

The role of our fathers:

… the boy is searching deeply throughout his childhood, beginning around age three, for a masculine model on which to build his sense of self.

Little boys begin to segregate by sex, to focus on rules rather than relationships, and to emphasize games of power, strength and achievement.

Boys have to give up mother for father, but who is father?

If father is not there to provide a confident, rich model of manhood, then the boy is left in a vulnerable position: having to distance himself from mother without a clear and understandable model of male gender upon which to base his emerging identity.

Distortions and myths shape normal men’s pictures of their fathers, based on the uneasy peripheral place fathers occupied in their homes,. Boys grow into men with a wounded father within, a conflicted inner sense of masculinity rooted in men’s experience of their fathers as rejecting, incompetent, or absent.

The interviews I have had with men in their thirties and forties convince me that the psychological and physical absence of fathers from their families is one of the great underestimated tragedies of our times. (Sternbach survey.. “only 15% of Sternbach’s cases [71] showed evidence of fathers appropriately involved with their sons, with a history of nurturance and trustworthy warmth and connection. (23% physically absent, 29% psychologically absent with work, 18% psychologically absent who were austere, moralistic and emotionally uninvolved, 15% dangerous and out of control).

The sense of loss extends into adulthood, as many sons try to resolve their sense of guilt, shame and anger at their fathers in silent, hidden and ambivalent ways.

Mothering is a close, tactile holding and caregiving, while fathering is more amorphous. We know our fathers from a distance; they may be warm but are usually more remote.

Early on we experience women as the ones who fill us up, who comfort and take care of us, without having an opportunity in growing up to learn how to fill ourselves and to feel full while truly separate from women.

The end result of the boy’s separation-individuation struggle is that men carry around as adults a burden of vulnerability, dependency, or emptiness within themselves, still grieving, reliving a time when going to mother for help as they wanted to was inappropriate, and they wouldn’t or couldn’t go to father with the confusion, anger, or sadness they felt.

… men subtly look to their wives to take care of them in ways that they cannot ask for directly and often are not themselves aware of.


Family Life Today

Current family situations are rekindling issues of separation and loss that men have not had a chance to work out in growing up.

In growing up men have great difficulty coming to terms with dependency and vulnerability, often because our fathers showed us that such feelings were unacceptable, that to be successful men, to win our father’s approval, achievement was what counted.

… men are not being sheltered from parts of life they had to repress or devalue in order to grow up.

Both sexes today seem to share a stereotype: that men are distant and unconnected, while relationships are the female specialty. Many people believe that women care more than men about love. Yet the division of the sexes into men as rational and women as feelers is simply untrue, a harmful and dangerous myth. For all that feminism has contributed to our culture, it has also brought with it a subtle idealization of women and a less subtle denigration or misunderstanding of men.

Much of the hunger for intimacy that many men reveal, is actually an attempt to heal the wound within ourselves, so that we can become more confident and nurturing as men.


UNSPOKEN DEBTS: MEN’S STRUGGLE TO SEPARATE FROM FATHER

What does stand out in men’s talk of their fathers is a mysterious, remote quality. Whether describing heroes, villains, or someone inbetween, most men know little of their fathers inner lives, what they thought and felt as men.

… but as we age into our thirties and forties the need for reconnecting becomes more pressing…

What is striking about Rubin’s data is how few fathers and sons achieve that connection, how many men experience “father hunger.”

Like the red-eyed financier, men often seem on the one hand to want their father’s love but also not to want it, to prove that they can get along without it.

For years my father felt like a heavy weight to me, an immoveable force I could neither approach nor avoid, pressing on me with his remote sadness and distant judgemental quality.


The Wounded Father

The wounded father is the internal sense of masculinity that men carry around within them. It is an inner image of father that we experience as judgemental and angry or, depending on our relationship with father, as needy and vulnerable. When a man says he can’t love his children because he wasn’t loved well enough, it is the wounded father he is struggling with.


The Wounded Father As Misidentification

The fundamental male vulnerability rooted in the experience of father lies in our fantasies and myths to explain why father isn’t there….

The son may experience his father’s preoccupation with work or emotional unavailability at home as his own fault. It’s because of something the son has done that father doesn’t pay attention to him.

Many men I have interviewed carry around a feeling of both having betrayed their father and having been betrayed by him.

… traditionally how men express love: by performing, being instrumental and taking care of, by protecting and providing.

…male undergraduates talked about themselves more with their mothers than with their fathers and were more satisfied with their relations with their mothers. The undergraduates complained most that their fathers were cold and uninvolved, giving too little of themselves. As we’ll see, men report being able to test limits and reality with mothers in ways they seem unable to with their fathers.

… you always had the sense that he had great feeling for you…

Dad, what are you feeling? Why do you work so hard? What do you expect of me? Why do I feel so angry and overburdened by you? .. all the existential questions that adolescent and even younger children normally have to answer as they grow. To fill the vacuum, many sons resort to fantasy, unconsciously developing explanations for why father is the way he is and why the relationship is the way it is. A man may feel unconsciously as if he drove his father out of the house, perhaps winning the oedipal battle…

The secretly Vulnerable Father

The traditional role of father in the family secretly communicated a sense of weakness to sons, which underlies the wounded father within men today.

He is the real-world caretaker, she the emotional caretaker. That arrangement gives mothers tremendous power in the family. They become the “affective switchboards” in the family, the center of the communication pattern; the kids turn to mother to deal with their dad, while father comes to depend on mother to tell him about what happened at home while he was gone…

As children get older, father can be pushed even farther to the periphery of the family. Here is where the family pattern of ‘protective denial’ becomes particularly destructive to sons, as their view of their father comes to be largely shaped by mother.

Some men may develop openly degraded, frightening ideas about their fathers.

… what happens to many sons in traditional marriages: They learn about their fathers through their mothers, absorbing a distorted image of their fathers and of masculinity.

Sons become uncomfortable allies of their mothers in the parental struggle with family roles and marital power.

Not only do grown sons struggle with a sense of not knowing how to behave as full men in the family, but also there is an emotional shadow over the family – it is a place where men become weak, needly little boys.

It is easy to underestimate the magical powers that men attribute to women. They are the masters of the interpersonal, feeling world in men’s unconscious, as our experience of women is rooted in early experiencing of mother. If women have the power to reduce men to weakness, a determination to avoid being vulnerable to one’s wife can form.

… the son may come to fear what he sees as the feminine wish to destroy men, to make them weak, needy, and helpless.


The Angry Father

Many men carry around within themselves an angry or judgemental father. We feel our fathers to be disappointed in us.

We unconsciously imagine that father will get even with us for our betrayal of him.

Many men idealize their fathers, make them bigger than life, because they once felt too strong for their own good and now imagine a father who will punish them for their sins.


The Fierce Tears of Our Fathers

Many of our fathers were not very happy men. Many of them were secretly angry or depressed, feeling considerable rage and depression at the traditional bargain they had made with their wives, exiled from their families, consigned to the public world of work.

There may be a kind of intergenerational revenge here, with some men acting out their father’s hidden rage at their wives and children, even as these grown men are trying to be more nurturant husbands and fathers.

The lack of a fuller emotional repertoire between father and son is often taken to mean that as sons get older they lack male models of emotional accessibility.

Our fathers perhaps secretly feared us too. The ambivalent love between fathers and sons is underestimated. It is the dark side of the high value boys are given in our society. Since so much of male identity is based on performance, sons will someday outdistance Dad. We become ambivalent objects, loved and feared by our fathers.

Our fear is of hurting him or being hurt by him. Those two themes are acted out over and over again in the adult life of men: the search for and rejection of our fathers.


The Mother’s Role

The result of the more open communication between son and mother is that the son may have a better, earlier chance to work out separation issues with her than with his father.

…boys often view their fathers as “helpful in a utilitarian sense” but “lacking significant personal and emotional involvement.”

One wonders what would happen if fathers played a more salient affective-expressive role during their sons’ early developmental years, particularly before age five.

Such rituals and rites defuse the intensity of the individual father-son relationship, providing both parties with what they so desperately need: a blessing from the make community, a welcome from fathers to their sons, and a thank-you from the sons to the fathers; a ritual purging of the tension and betrayals of growing up male.


The Impossible Wish to Be a Good Son

I have the impression that today the wish for forgiveness and reconciliation with father ofen goes unmet. Within the family fathers cannot communicate a sense of benevolent masculinity to their sons, and culturally we have distorted social rituals and initiation ceremonies. The rites of passage common to men in adolescence and young adulthood today involve joining such institutions as the army, football teams, medical schools and large corporations. Those institutions pay upon the young man’s wish for an idealized father to love him, offering an exaggeratedly masculine way to live up and be a good son.

If mothers become life giving earth in the unconscious of men, then fathers become wrathful, judgmental gods.

What do not go away are the sons’ wishes to obtain their fathers’ love and to be good son’s at last.

… to pay back an unspoken debt, in a word to be a good son, finally, at the very same time as we confront social demands that we be truly different from our fathers.


The Wish for Odysseus

… emphasize men’s need to heal the wounded father within…

.. the great recognition scene in the Odyssey captures the wishes of both men better than the more familiar Oedipal drama…

“When the great warrior King Odysseus returns home from more than a decade of wandering he and the princely Telemachus hardly know each other. In a stunning moment the unconquerable warrier reveals himself to his teenage son:

‘I am that father whom your boyhood lacked and suffered pain for lack of. I am he… This is not princely to be swept away by wonder at your father’s presence. No other Odysseus will ever come, for he and I are one, the same…

Throwing his arms around theis marvel of a father, Telemachus began to weep. Salt tears rose from the wells of longing in both men, and cries burst forth from both as keen and fluttering as those of the great taloned hawk, whose nestlings farmers take before they fly. So helplessly they cried pouring out tears, and might have gone on weeping till sundown.”

The wells of longing in both men. The Odysseus myth points to a deep yearning for each other in both father and son, and it contains lesson for our times.

Odysseus shows his son how to be a man and gives him confidence in his own strength.

We need the father who helps us define masculine strength in a changing world, what Robert Bly has colled “the moist father,” strong and present man in new, unfamiliar situations.

We have grown up thinking of Oedipal rivalry between father and son, the guilty wish to surpass the father, but we need also attend to the Odysseus theme, the wish to be like father, to find a father, a sturdy man we can rely on.

Until a man “names his father,” sees him clearly as who he is and was, it is that much more difficult for him to grow up himself and become a father to his children, a husband to a wife, or a mentor to the younger generation at work. That is every man’s task of healing the wounded father within.”

Saturday, August 4, 2007

Need reasons to start a men's group?

No one does a better job at describing where men are coming from... than Ken Druck in his book:


THE SECRETS MEN KEEP

Here are some of the insights that he shares in this book. A collection of best quotes....

INTRODUCTION

The Major Areas in Which Men Keep Secrets

“A majority of men did not receive the love, approval, and direct contact they wanted from their fathers… many are still tied to their fathers for approval, whether those fathers are dead, live far away, or have become estranged.”

“Men hide their desire for friendship and support from other males…. Many men have stopped believing that close companionship is possible, except with women.”

“But few men have one close male friend in whom they can confide.”

“Men use the workplace as a major burial ground for their secrets…. Many men define themselves almost solely on the basis of what they do for a living.”

“Men are much more dependent upon women than they admit.”

“Wives, lovers, and mothers have always known that even the most powerful men are often dependent.”

“Most men were raised by their mothers and are still dependent upon them in ways they never suspected. Until men resolve their feelings toward their mothers, it will be difficult for them to establish and maintain a mature and satisfying relationship with another woman.”

“Men feel powerless and angry toward women.”

“Men deny themselves the right to feel uncertain, fearful, and hurt.”

The Benefits of Acknowledging Our Secrets:

“Disclosure is the least exploited form of power known to men.”

“We fulfill our human need to be known and accepted. By hiding our true selves and projecting false images in order to gain the approval of others, we never test our actual worth.”

What is a Man to Be ?

“Men today no longer know what it means to be a man. We are bombarded on every side by conflicting and contradictory signals…”


Who is the Successful Man of the Eighties?

“Man must broaden their definition of success to include both the professional and personal spheres. To be a success in the eighties, men must learn to reach down inside themselves to make contract with what they feel, what they want, and what they believe it means to be a success.”

1. FEELINGS: THE SECRET GARDEN MEN ARE FORBIDDEN TO ENTER

On Being a Man

“To be strong a man must be able to stand utterly alone, able to meet and deal with life relying solely upon his own inner resources.”

“The knowledge explosion affects directly men’s influence as fathers.”

What Price Glory?

“By choosing to go the way of concealment rather than that of openness, we men have too often brought upon ourselves sickness, misunderstanding, and self-alienation. We have had to pay a stiff price for the right to “be a man.”

“In addition, large numbers of contemporary men pick loneliness as one of their chief burdens.”

Men Behind Walls

“There’s no way to reach my husband, to know what is really going on inside him…”

“ ‘Walls’ are defenses we use to put distance between ourselves and others.”

How We Sidestep Our Feelings

“We rationalize a course of inaction by telling ourselves, ‘what good is it going to do to talk about it? That’s not going to change anything!”

“We escape into new roles or hide behind old ones.”

“(we say)… these feelings will pass.”

“we keep busy…”

“We change one feeling into another. (act angry when hurt)”

“We deny the feeling outright”

“We put our feelings on hold - compartmentalize them or put them in a back file.”

“We dull or dilute our feelings… with drugs or alcohol”

“We perform a ‘thinking bypass’ – replacing our feelings with thought or logic…

“We tense our bodies, so that we do not feel anything…”

“We let our women do our feeling for us …”

“We avoid situations”

“Originally meant to inform us, our feelings instead have become a threat to us.”


What’s In It For Us When We Acknowledge Our Feelings?

“Feelings motivate us…. Create a healthy environment for us…. Connect us to other people…. build confidence …. help us make the right decisions.”


Three Steps for Getting in Closer Touch with our Feelings

“Keep in mind that our feelings are usually one or two word adjectives (angry, sad, scared, and happy) … make certain you are expressing feelings and not opinions.

“We must learn to read our body’s emotional signals”

“(you should)… talk out our feelings with trusted friend(s).”

“The reality is that we all need and benefit from support, caring, guidance, and understanding. Women know this. Most of them have friends with whom they can talk about their feelings. Many men do not.”


2. LIFE WITH FATHER: OR, “WHO WAS THAT MASKED MAN?”

The Father Within Us

“When my Uncle Nathan was 70, he visited his father’s grave tucked away in a corner of a cemetery in the Bronx. He stood there facing the headstone, the November wind ruffling his silver hair. Suddenly, his body started shaking. Tears streaked his face. “Dad, you never even put your arms around me,” he sobbed, spilling out a secret grief that he had carried around with him all these years. “You never touched me. You never hugged me. Where were you when I needed you?”

“It may surprise us to know that the most powerful common denominator influencing men’s lives today is the relationship we had with our fathers. The events ad circumstances may have taken place years, even decades, ago. They may appear irrelevant to our lives in the present. But if we look beyond the surface, we will discover, as my Uncle Nathan did, that Dad is still very much with us today. Much of our behavior and many of our attitudes toward living can be traced to our fathers. Whether our dad was physically or psychologically absent, whether he died when we were young or is still alive at a ripe old age, whether we consider him a good father or a poor one, our fathers are in us. Every man hears the silent voice of his father inside his own head.”

“And some, like my Uncle Nathan, will journey to their own graves with that secret longing unsatisfied…”

“More often, our stories uncover a deep yearning for Father’s love and acceptance. ‘Our fathers wanted to raise us; but they didn’t want to know us,’ was the way one man stated his disappointment.”


Who was that Masked Man?

“Rather, my father, like the Lone Ranger, was always riding in and out of town.”

“I did not know. My father was a stranger to me in so many ways. The world of his workplace was a mystery to me. He was a very private man. I knew little about his dreams, his fears, his feelings toward me. These were his secrets.”

“For many years he had masked his true identity behind a relentless commitment to his business and his exhaustion at the end of the workday.”

“I secretly resented the fact that my dad put his business ahead of his family and gave so little of himself directly to me. I wanted far more fathering that he was able to give me.”

“ ‘Don’t upset your father,’ my mother always cautioned us.”

“And so I grew up with the feeling that my father was unapproachable. My resentment built up over the years as I saw the kind of fathering some of my buddies enjoyed in their homes.”

“… by making my father the ‘bad guy’ and judging his lifestyle as ‘wrong,’ I had made some important decisions about my own life. And in the process I had also denied a rich and vital part of my male heritage. I had denied the industrious, strong willed, and confident part of my father that was in me. Most important, I had denied the love and gratitude I did have for my dad.”


3. REACHING OUT TO FATHER


Eight Benefits of a Reconciliation with Father

“It will allow us to be our own man, not our father’s man… allows us to achieve a communication with him…”

“The ‘fringe benefits’ of a love relationship with our living father are unlimited. We have opened the doors to each other’s lives and the richness that comes in sharing special moments, supporting one another’s goals, assisting one another in times of need, and generating newfound affection for one another.”

“Face to face, man to man, you are your father’s equal. You no longer need to ‘prove’ yourself by doing ‘manly’ deeds. Your father accepts and loves you for the person you are.”

“The confidence born of a loving, healthy father-son relationship sets a precedent for other relationships in the lives of both the father and the son.”

“We can learn from the unique textures each seaon brings as we partake of each other’s lives. Autumn remembers spring, as spring looks on autumn’s rich colors.”


The Hostage Game

“The Hostage Game is another ploy we often use when we refuse to accept our own responsibility for a fractured father-son relationship… we make our fathers the ‘Bad Guy’… we make what our father did unforgivable… we foul up our own lives and blame our father…”

“We blame his failure on his job, health, personality, wife, or upbringing. In this hostage drama we cast our father as the victim of circumstances beyond his control. We perpetually let him off the hook, telling ourselves that he is not responsible for his behavior.”

“We hold Dad hostage to Mother’s bitterness. We see him through her eyes. And this can provide a dangerous distortion, especially if there has been a divorce. We can easiliy end up with what the poet Robert Bly has called ‘a wounded image of our father,” caused less by his actions than by our mother’s perception of those actions.

“Broad-based indictments of our father also fail to consider two other essential factors: our father’s identity as a unique individual and the family roles men had during the earlier part of this century.”


4. MAN TO MAN: WHY A GOOD FRIEND IS HARD TO FIND

Male Friendships as second-class Relationships

“… a major problem of contemporary men – their failure to establish close friendships with other men, friendships in which they feel secure enough to confide their deepest fears and feelings. The sorry fac is that men today often have no close male friends. This is so common that it is taken for granted and rarely commented upon. Many of the men I counsel admit they do not have one intimate male friend in whom they can place complete trust and confidence.”

“The sad fact is that most men simply do not trust one another.”

“When we marry, we cease spending much time or energy nurturning and developing close friendships with other men. We focus our attention instead on our wives, our families, and the ‘contacts’ we make at work.”


The Friendship Rut

“Many men have come to view the need for a friend as a bit of an embarrassment, a throwback to adolescence”

“Six Don’ts of Male Friendship: Don’t let your guard down; don’t show too much emotion; don’t become too involved, friendly or frivolous; don’t let on how much you really care; don’t touch one another; don’t act like a sissy or appear feminine in any way.”

“Usually, when I ask men to list their male friends, they give me the names of friends from their past – buddies from their youth, fraternity brothers in college, or guys they know when they were in the armed forces.”


The Walls We Hide Behind

“But just the opposite happens when we are with other men. Most men would be hard put to define precisely what they like and do not like in other men.”

“We are reluctant to pay other men compliments.”

The wall of competition: “Two men meet and introduce themselves. Almost immediately each one asks himself, ‘How much better or less a man am I than he?”

The wall of Women: “Some men use the women in their lives, including their wives, girlfriends, mothers, and secretaries, as buffers between themselves and other men. It is their way of avoiding any sort of direct contact with other men. For some men, this is a throwback to their childhood when Mom was always there to act as an intermediary between them and their fathers.”

The wall of fear: “Men’s fear of rejection and judgment at the hands of other men constitutes another major wall. We are more sensitive to what other men think than many of us let on. The Wall of Fear is well guarded. We keep our insecurities at work a secret from our male colleagues for fear they may use that information against us.”

“Many men fear that if they get too close to another man physically or emotionally, others will perceive them as ‘gay.’ It is an unfortunate aspect of our ture that the American man’s preoccupation with losing his ‘maleness’ can often preclude the kind of healthy close male camaraderie that exists in other cultures.”

The Wall of Ignorance: “The Wall of ignorance is perhaps the saddest of them all. Because we never allow ourselves an opportunity to get to know other men in ways that permit a mutual exchange of feelings, we never understand the way in which men are truly different from as well as similar to us.”

The Benefits of Man-to-Man Friendships

“Most men feel more comfortable drawing their closest friends from women rather than other men. We fall back on our wives, lovers, mothers, sisters, and daughters. We decide early on that women make better friends.”

“Men feel safer talking to a woman about their fears and uncertainties than to another man. We perceive women as more loving and trustworthy than other men.”

“We validate our experiences as a man… once we open our world to another man, we learn that we are not alone in our fears, insecurities, uncertainties, and desires.”

“Frank and honest exchanges of experiences allow us to gain a fresh and clear perspective on ourselves.”

“We lessen our dependencies on women… Friendships with other men put a balance back into our lives and strengthen our marriages because there is less emotional clinging to the women in our lives.”

“We develop our skills at intimacy… Men who achieve intimacy with other men enjoy a sense of acceptance by their peers. We become more certain of who we are. We develop more self-esteem.”

“Male friends help us in times of crises with women.”

“Friends protect us against life’s stresses … a buffer against such crises as the loss of a wife or job, a chronic illness, and th psychological stresses of aging.”

“Friends minimize loneliness… become valuable resources… reaffirm our sense of being alive.”

Man to Man

“Men are adept at talking about things rather than what they feel about those things. Our willingness to be emotionally honest and vulnerable can make the difference between an acquaintanceship and a friendship.”

“I learned more about him and he about me in those two days than in twenty years of friendship. What forced it was that we didn’t have anything to lose and everything to gain.”


Friday, August 3, 2007

FROM A Circle of Men - KAUTH

A Circle of Men - Kauth


“Only men understand the secret fears that go with the territory of masculinity” –

Sam Keen, Fire in the Belly

It is becoming increasingly apparent to the mental health establishment that small support groups are a vital source of the supportive community feeling that so many people desperately need in this fast-moving age of alienation.

Being in a group is a move in the direction of positive change. The process of being with other people in a safe, supportive situation can actually change who we think we are.

Time commitment – A basic agreement from each member of the group to stay with the group for a certain period of time is essential.

Community commitment – Community is a safe place precisely because no one is attempting to heal or convert you, to fix you, to change you. Instead, the members accept you as you are. You are free to be you. And being so free, you are free to discard defenses, masks, disguises: free to seek your own psychological and spiritual health.

Meeting the challenge of opening ourselves to others and finding acceptance is a vital step toward becoming able to know our own power.

First Meeting:

Let’s get started. Please say your name, tell us whether you’ve ever participated in a men’s group or men’s weekend before. What is one thing you would like to get from this group? Or alternatively, what in the materials that I sent you stands out in your mind or how it was a factor in your decision to come over this evening.

What I would like to do is for each man to become aware of his immediate goals and intentions for himself in this group.

Rules, Agreements and guidelines:

1. Take full responsibility for yourself. This is your group and you are responsible for getting what you want.

2. Tell the truth. To the best of your ability, let others know what is happening for you.

Rules, Agreements and guidelines:

1. If you are going to be late or absent, call someone. This saves waiting and wondering.

2. Don’t leave the group permanently without saying goodbye. An unannounced dropout is like a death in the family and can result in much confusion for other group members.

Rules, Agreements and Guidelines:

1. Speak freely and openly. Men need not ask permission to speak, intervene, move around , or contribute in any fashion. However, it is easier if only one man speaks at a time.

2. Speak directly to another man. Instead of “Bob seems sad,” speak to him: “Bob, you seem sad to me,” or “I imagine you are angry right now.”

3. Any man may “pass.” If someone is uncomfortable with a topic or does not wish to disclose personal information at any time, he should feel completely comfortable in not expressing himself.

4. Be aware of feelings. Express them. Because avoidance of feelings is so ingrained, give special attention to how men feel, and encourage feeling statements. “I feel happy” or “I’m afraid.”

5. Be here and now. Emphasize the present. As much as possible, stay in the here and now by describing present-time experience.

6. Use “I” statements. Rather than using the editorial “we” or “you”, speak for yourself. “I feel comfortable.”

7. Avoid questions, especially “why” questions. Before asking a question (or answering one) consider the statement behind your question and express the direct statement instead. Example:

Question: “Why are you looking at me?”

Statement: “I’m not comfortable when you look at me like that.”

8. Avoid judgements; be descriptive. Describe the man’s behavior and your response. In this way you do not lay a triop on someone else, aned you take responsibility for your own reactions.. Example:

Instead of: “You’re really off base.”

You might say: “When you ramble on, I lose a sense of where you are going, and

I start to feel anxious.”

Thursday, August 2, 2007

How to Keep Men's Groups Energized

How to Keep Men's Groups Energized -By Tony Bushman

Invariably your men's group will become accustomed to the way it functions and may even get bored. How do you help keep the group energized? Here are some suggestions:

Preventive measures:

Invite new people to join the group every six months

Create variety in your format - e.g. dinner, camping, workshops, discussion, play, work projects, focus on a chapter in a book, etc,

Welcoming attitude:

Greet each person. Show genuine pesonal interest in him. Introduce regulars to new attendees. Explain procedures to visitors. Call each newcomer the next day and invite him to the next meeting.

Reactive measures

Deal with things immediately. The actions of the group provide a crucible for dealing with the real world. Dysfunctions in the group mirror what is happening elsewhere. It is a good and safe forum in which to deal with with behavior that needs improvement.

Reflect behavior:

When you notice that the group is going through the doldrums, you can almost always energizes the group by asking, "I sense the group is losing energy. What do you think is happening?" The resulting discussion almost always refocuses the group and enables them to energize.